Stock Meadow · Investing styles

Value vs growth stocks: what each style measures and how to test it

Value and growth are the two best-known investing styles. This guide explains the measures behind each, the blends in between, the sector tilts to watch, and how to score and test both on the 3,000 largest US stocks and 20 years of history.

Updated · By Stock Meadow · About us

Value and growth in plain words

  • Value investing looks for stocks priced low compared with the company's earnings, cash flow, sales or assets. The idea is that the market has been too pessimistic and the price may not reflect what the business is worth.
  • Growth investing looks for companies whose sales and earnings are rising faster than most. Investors accept a higher price today for the expectation that profits will be much larger later.

The two are not opposites in every case. They describe what you measure first: the price you pay, or the pace at which the business grows.

The measures behind each style

Common value and growth measures
StyleMeasureWhat it shows
ValueP/E ratioPrice for each dollar of yearly earnings (lower is cheaper)
ValuePrice to free cash flowPrice for each dollar of cash left after investment
ValueEV/EBITDAThe whole company's value, debt included, against operating earnings
ValuePrice to salesPrice for each dollar of sales; useful when earnings are thin
ValuePrice to bookPrice against shareholders' equity; common for banks
GrowthRevenue growthHow fast sales rose over the last year
GrowthEPS growthHow fast earnings per share rose
GrowthOperating cash flow growthWhether the cash the business brings in is rising too
GrowthForward PEGP/E divided by analysts' expected growth; links the two styles

Swipe sideways to see every column.

In Stock Meadow's stock scoring model, the Value style weighs P/E (3), price to free cash flow (2), EV/EBITDA (2) and price to sales (1). The Growth style weighs revenue growth (3), EPS growth (2), operating cash flow growth (1) and forward PEG (1). You can change any weight or add measures of your own.

Blends between the two

Many well-known approaches mix value and growth, or value with another signal:

  • GARP (growth at a reasonable price), the approach Peter Lynch described: growing earnings, but not at any price.
  • Trending Value, from James O'Shaughnessy: take the cheapest stocks on several value measures, then rank them by recent price strength.
  • Magic Formula, from Joel Greenblatt: a high earnings yield (value) combined with a high return on capital (quality).

All 9 scoring models are explained in the user guide.

Watch the sector tilt

Ranking the whole market on value measures tends to fill the list with sectors that are usually priced low, such as financials, energy and utilities. Ranking on growth tends to favour technology and health care. That means a value-versus-growth comparison is often partly a comparison of sectors.

To separate the two, turn on Rank within sector in the stock scoring model: each company is then compared with its own sector, so a cheap software company and a cheap bank can both rank high.

Score value and growth stocks, step by step

  1. Open the stock scoring model and choose the Value style. Every stock gets a score from 0 to 100 against the rest of the market.
  2. Add a market-cap floor or sector filter if you want to narrow the field, and turn on Rank within sector if you want a sector-neutral list.
  3. Add a quality or trend measure, such as return on invested capital or 12-1 momentum, with a small weight, to push likely value traps down the list.
  4. Save the screen, then switch the style to Growth and save that too, so you can compare the two lists side by side.
  5. Open a company to see why it scored as it did: each measure's value, rank and weight is listed.

Test both styles on past data

From either screen, press Backtest this model. The model backtester scores the largest US stocks of each past date using only the data public at that time, holds the top-scored ones and follows the hypothetical result over 5, 10 or 20 years, with companies that were later delisted included.

  • Add IWD (Russell 1000 Value) and IWF (Russell 1000 Growth) as comparisons to see your model next to the two style funds.
  • Look at the year-by-year table: styles tend to take turns, so a single total return hides long stretches in each direction.
  • Forward PEG needs analysts' forecasts, which can't be rebuilt for past dates, so the backtest leaves it out of the Growth style and says so above the results.

Backtest results are simulated and depend on the settings and dates chosen. Past results don't predict future results.

Pitfalls with each style

  • Value traps. A low price can reflect a business in decline. Check quality and trend measures, not just ratios.
  • Growth that doesn't last. Fast growth often slows, and a high price leaves little room for disappointment.
  • One-off earnings. A single large gain or loss can make P/E or EPS growth look misleading. Look at several years on the company's statement pages.
  • Losses. Companies with losses have no meaningful P/E; price to sales or EV/EBITDA can help, with care.

Use these styles as ways to organise your research, not as answers. For research only, not investment advice.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between value and growth stocks?
Value stocks are priced low compared with what the company earns, owns or pays out today, measured by ratios such as P/E or EV/EBITDA. Growth stocks are companies whose sales and earnings are rising fast; investors usually pay a higher price for each dollar of today's earnings in exchange for that growth.
Can a stock be both value and growth?
Yes. A company can grow quickly and still be priced modestly, and that mix is exactly what GARP (growth at a reasonable price) looks for. Many stocks also sit in the middle on both measures, so the labels describe a range rather than two separate boxes.
What is a value trap?
A stock that looks cheap because its business is shrinking or in trouble, so the low price is deserved. Checking quality and trend measures, such as return on capital, free cash flow and price momentum, helps tell a cheap stock from a struggling one.
Which has done better over time, value or growth?
It depends heavily on the period chosen. Each style has had long stretches of leading and lagging. The model backtester lets you test both on your own settings and dates, with the Russell 1000 Value (IWD) and Growth (IWF) funds as comparisons. Past results don't predict future results.
Is this investment advice?
No. This page explains common definitions and how to examine them with Stock Meadow's tools. For research only, not investment advice.

Compare value and growth yourself

Sign up free for a 7-day trial, no card needed, choose the Value or Growth style in the stock scoring model, then press Backtest this model. Already a member? Go straight in.

Open the stock scoring model