Stock Meadow · Calculator
Beneish M-Score calculator
Enter two years of figures from a company's annual reports and see its Beneish M-Score, with each of the eight ratios behind it. A high score is a reason to look closer at the accounts, not proof of anything.
Updated · By Stock Meadow · About us
Work out an M-Score
Type the figures from the company's last two annual reports. Use the same unit for every line (for example millions of dollars). Nothing you type leaves your browser.
The result appears here once the figures are in. To see how it works first, press Fill in an example.
Stock Meadow has the Beneish M-Score of about 3,000 US stocks.
A stock above the warning level carries an earnings-quality flag, and you can filter the whole market on the score. It is a reason to look closer, not proof of anything.
Start a free 7-day trialNo card needed to start.
For research only, not investment advice.
The eight ratios and their weights
Messod Beneish published the M-Score in 1999. It compares this year's accounts with last year's through eight ratios, each picking up a pattern that showed up more often in companies later found to have overstated their earnings.
M-Score = −4.84 + the eight ratios below, each multiplied by its weight
| Ratio | How it is worked out | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Receivables index (DSRI) | (receivables ÷ sales) this year ÷ the same last year | 0.920 |
| Gross margin index (GMI) | gross margin last year ÷ gross margin this year | 0.528 |
| Asset quality index (AQI) | (1 − (current assets + property, plant and equipment) ÷ total assets) this year ÷ the same last year | 0.404 |
| Sales growth index (SGI) | sales this year ÷ sales last year | 0.892 |
| Depreciation index (DEPI) | (depreciation ÷ (depreciation + property, plant and equipment)) last year ÷ the same this year | 0.115 |
| Overheads index (SGAI) | (SG&A ÷ sales) this year ÷ the same last year | −0.172 |
| Accruals to total assets (TATA) | (net income − operating cash flow) ÷ total assets, this year | 4.679 |
| Leverage index (LVGI) | ((current liabilities + long-term debt) ÷ total assets) this year ÷ the same last year | −0.327 |
Swipe sideways to see every column.
Seven of the ratios are indexes that read about 1 when nothing changed from one year to the next; the eighth, accruals, is a share of total assets. Six of the eight push the score up when they rise: receivables growing faster than sales, a shrinking gross margin, more of the balance sheet in assets that are neither current nor plant, fast sales growth, slower depreciation, and profit running ahead of cash. Overheads and leverage carry a negative weight in the model.
This is the formula as Stock Meadow works it out for every stock. Gross margin is revenue minus cost of revenue, over revenue. A blank long-term debt counts as zero. For more background, read the Beneish M-Score page in the metric glossary.
Where to find the figures
Everything comes from a company's annual report (Form 10-K for US companies), which prints the latest year beside the year before:
- Income statement: revenue, cost of revenue, SG&A expense (the overheads line) and net income.
- Cash flow statement: net cash provided by operating activities, and depreciation and amortization, which is usually listed there even when the income statement doesn't show it.
- Balance sheet: receivables (net), total current assets, property, plant and equipment (net), total assets, total current liabilities and long-term debt. Use the figure at each fiscal year end.
The two years have to be full fiscal years, one after the other, in the same currency. Type a loss or a cash outflow as a negative number, with a minus sign or in brackets.
Reading the score
A lower (more negative) score is better. Above −1.78 is the warning level: on Stock Meadow, a stock above it carries an earnings-quality flag. At or below −1.78 there is no flag.
A high score is a reason to look closer, not evidence of wrongdoing. The model only sees patterns in numbers. A company that is growing fast, has bought another business or has changed what it does can trip several of the ratios for ordinary reasons.
The working under the score shows which ratios are behind it. That tells you where to look in the accounts: a high receivables index points to the revenue and receivables notes, a high accruals figure to the gap between profit and cash.
What the charts show
Under the score, the same eight ratios are drawn four ways:
- The score against the warning level. The score on a bar split at −1.78. A small mark shows −2.48, what a company would score if nothing had changed from one year to the next and its profit were fully backed by cash.
- Seven indexes against 1.00. Seven of the ratios compare this year with the year before, so 1.00 means no change. The darker bars are the ones moving the score toward the warning level. For the overheads and leverage indexes that is a reading below 1, because their weights are negative.
- Accruals against zero. The eighth ratio is not a comparison with last year: it is net income minus operating cash flow, as a share of total assets. It has its own chart so it is not read against 1.00 by mistake.
- What each index adds. A table of weight × value for each index, largest first, with how far each moves the score from −2.48.
A bar that stands out says where to start reading the accounts. It is a reason to look closer, not proof of wrongdoing.
What the M-Score leaves out
- It flags, it does not find. Many companies above the warning level have done nothing wrong, and a low score does not clear a company.
- Growth and acquisitions distort it. A company that doubles its sales by merging with another will score high on sales growth and usually on several other ratios.
- It does not fit financial companies. Stock Meadow works out no M-Score for them.
- Some companies have no score. A zero or negative gross margin in either year, a ratio that would divide by zero (no receivables or no overheads the year before, for example), or a result beyond ±100 leaves it blank.
- It was fitted to past cases. The weights come from companies studied in the 1980s and early 1990s, and may miss newer accounting practices.
For research only, not investment advice.
Frequently asked questions
- How is the Beneish M-Score calculated?
- Eight ratios are worked out from two years of accounts: receivables against sales, gross margin, asset quality, sales growth, depreciation, overheads, leverage and accruals. Each is multiplied by a fixed weight, and the results are added to a constant of −4.84. The sum is the M-Score.
- What does a Beneish M-Score above −1.78 mean?
- It is a warning sign that reported earnings may be less reliable, and a reason to read the company's statements and notes more closely. It is not evidence of wrongdoing: fast growth, an acquisition or a change in the business can raise the score for ordinary reasons.
- Is a lower M-Score better?
- Yes. A lower (more negative) score means the eight ratios show fewer of the patterns the model looks for. Stock Meadow raises an earnings-quality flag only when the score is above −1.78.
- Which figures do I need for the M-Score?
- For the latest fiscal year and the one before: revenue, cost of revenue, SG&A expense, depreciation and amortization, receivables, current assets, net property, plant and equipment, total assets, current liabilities and long-term debt. For the latest year only: net income and operating cash flow.
- Does this calculator match Stock Meadow's own M-Score?
- Yes. It applies the same eight ratios and weights Stock Meadow uses for every stock, counts a blank long-term debt as zero, and gives no score where the site gives none: when gross margin was zero or negative in either year, when one of the ratios would divide by zero, or when the result is beyond ±100.
- Does the M-Score work for banks and insurers?
- No. Ratios such as gross margin and receivables against sales do not fit a bank's or an insurer's accounts. Stock Meadow does not work out an M-Score for financial companies.
- Which index moves the M-Score most?
- It depends on the company. The table under the score lists what each of the eight indexes adds, largest first, and how far each moves the score from −2.48, the score of a company whose figures did not change from one year to the next and whose profit is fully backed by cash. Accruals carry the largest weight (4.679), so profit running well ahead of cash moves the score more than any single ratio does.
Stock Meadow has the Beneish M-Score of about 3,000 US stocks.
A stock above the warning level carries an earnings-quality flag, and you can filter the whole market on the score. It is a reason to look closer, not proof of anything. Sign up free for a 7-day trial, no card needed. Already a member? Go straight in.
Open the stock screener